Title: The Hot Rock
Author: Donald E. Westlake
Publication Year: 1970
Pages: 224
Genre: Crime Fiction Count for Year: 13
Title: Bank Shot
Author: Donald E. Westlake
Publication Year: 1972
Pages: 249
Genre: Crime Fiction
Count for Year: 14
How I discovered
My brother-in-law introduced me to Westlake last year and I’ve read a few of his Parker series, written under his pseudonym Richard Stark, plus a few others that aren’t part of any series. I had heard of the Dortmunder series, but since I’m such a stickler for reading books in order, I wasn’t sure that our library had all of them. As of this past week, I’ve learned that the library has all but two of them, and a Facebook friend is going to “hook me up” with the other two in the near future.
Review
The premise for each is extremely simple: robbery. In the first book, the prize is a $500,000 emerald; in the second, a bank. The protagonist in both is John Archibald Dortmunder, whom is described on the book jacket of the very first novel thusly:
John Archibald Dortmunder is the archetypal criminal manqué. Brought up in an orphanage in the Midwest, he is 37 years old, served in the “police action” in Korea, was arrested twice for robbery following his release from the service, and was briefly married to a nightclub entertainer named Honeybun Bazoom from whom he was granted an unconditional divorce.
In each book, he is joined by a team of criminals. Two of them belong to the team in both books, with a few others only in each. The two constant characters, at least, for these first two Dortmunder books, are Kelp, “an ex-con with a penchant for stealing cars with MD license plates,” and Stan Murch, described as “a crook who lives with his mother, a cab driver and collects stereo records of ‘Sounds of Indianapolis.’”
In the first, he is also joined by Roger Chefwick, who is the team’s “lockman” and Greenwood; in the second, a girlfriend May, another lockman Herman X (who as you might have guessed it belongs to a Black Muslim-like group), Murch’s mother and Kelp’s hapless nephew Victor, who brings the team the proposition to rob a bank.
Whereas in the character of Parker, Westlake creates a hard-boiled serious master criminal, in the character of Dortmunder, he creates a hard-boiled comic foil to Parker — not that Parker doesn’t have his moments of humor. However, in Dortmunder, Westlake brings the comic more to the forefront.
In the first, the comedy is so over the top, from a car crash into the New York Coliseum, a helicopter attack on a police station and a break-out from an insane asylum using a locomotive stolen from a nearby amusement park, that it stretched the credibility just a little too much for me. While I couldn’t help but chuckle at some of the escapades, I also was like, “Uh huh. Sure. I bet that could happen.” as I rolled my eyes.
In contrast, in the second, the comedy stays on target, with one joke: that the team is going to steal a bank, yes, steal a bank. The bank is a temporary bank set in a trailer while a new one is being constructed nearby. What follows is, at times, laugh-out loud funny, for example, as this scene when the bank is reported missing:
“Uhhhh,” said the radio. “Dispatcher.”
“Is this car nine?”
“This is car nine, it isn’t here.”
The dispatcher felt a sudden sense of panic. The trouble wasn’t there? He looked again at the red light, which was still lit even though the buzzer was off, and it was number fift-two. He looked at his typewritten sheet, and fifty-two was the temporary bank. “Well, it was there,” he said.
“I know it was here,” said car nine. “I saw it only five minutes ago. But it isn’t here now.”
The dispatcher by now was completely bewildered. “You saw it five minutes ago?”
“Last time we went by.”
“Now wait a minute,” the dispatcher said. His voice was rising, and the other two dispatchers looked at him oddly. A dispatcher was supposed to stay calm. “Wait a minute,” the dispatcher repeated. “You knew about this trouble five minutes ago and you didn’t report it?”
“No, no, no,” car nine said, and another voice behind it said, “Let me have that.” Then it apparently took over the microphone, becoming louder when it said, “Dispatcher, this is Officer Bolt. We are the scene, and the bank is gone.”
…
The dispatcher, his voice, nearly as thin as the air where the bank had been, finally said, “The bank is gone?”
“That’s right,” Officer Bolt said, nodding in irritation. “From far away, he could hear more sirens coming. “Some son of a bitch,” he said, “has stole the bank.”
My rating for The Hot Rock: 3 out of 5.
My rating for Bank Shot: 4 out of 5.
My rating system:
5- Classic, must read
4- Worth owning a copy
3- Worth picking up at library
2- Worth skimming at the bookstore
1- Worth being a doorstop










